< .comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Massachusetts Liberal

Observations on politics, the media and life in Massachusetts and beyond from the left side of the road.

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Hip check

Let's start with a few basics: political debates in June are a snooze, even if the Globe opts to put the story on Page One.

They are an even bigger snooze when they are three-way affairs, held on the radio at 8 a.m. And let's throw in the fact the moderator is not a journalist, but a former house speaker, turned convicted felon turned talk show host.

So there's very little to pick through from Tom Finneran's time with Deval Patrick, Charlie Baker and Tim Cahill. Mimicking the current campaign dynamic, it sounded as if everyone dumped on Charlie.

In fact, there's only exchange that leaves me looking for an answer: where did Finneran have his own hip replaced? The Herald's Jessica Heslam makes note of an exchange, without offering the answer:

Finneran walked away with one of the better soundsbites (sic) when he brought up the governor’s recent hip replacement surgery at Massachusetts General Hospital while pressing him on health care.

Finneran pointed out that Milton Hospital and Carney Hospital are close to the governor’s Milton home and offer orthopedic surgery at “considerable less price.”

“And you chose the Cadillac of Cadillacs,” Finneran said. “Is it one rule for you and a different rule for all the rest of us?”

Finneran’s Cadillac comment invoked Patrick’s rough start in the Corner Office and his ill-advised decision to cruise around in a pricey Cadillac.

We know Mistah Speakah had similar work done and that he is a resident of Mattapan, also close to Milton and Carney hospitals. But as the moderator, he felt he was under no obligation to disclose that fact or where his own surgery was performed. He didn't even have to tell whether either of those institutions even perform joint replacements.

Major league cheap shot in my book -- something debate moderators are not supposed to engage in.

It would seem a golden rule going forward would be that debate hosts hold the candidates -- and themselves -- to high standards. The public does have a right to know the biases at work.

Labels: , , , ,


Blogger massmarrier said...

Amusing...the Globe reported in December 2003 that "Though it can be dangerous to read too much between the lines, on the day before he entered Mass. General Hospital for hip surgery, Finneran had enough kick left to fire a shot against the importation of discount-price prescription drugs from Canada." A Cadillac must have room for more than one pol.

June 18, 2010 7:40 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home